Community Benefits Agreement: Industry Stakeholders Taking Action

Community Benefits AgreementOn Monday, July 16, BC’s NDP government revealed details of a highly controversial “Community Benefits Agreement” which goes far beyond the traditional CBA model. 

VICA certainly supports any initiative that promotes apprentices, indigenous peoples, and women in the trades but, in doing so, any agreements must be good for all Vancouver Islanders and British Columbians.

As champions of fair, open, and transparent procurement practices, we denounce any subjective or preferential eligibility requirements. As Canadians, we object to this assault on our freedom of thought and peaceful assembly as guaranteed by the Canadian Charter of Rights & Freedoms. Here's what you need to know, and what you can do about it.

What It Is:

  1. A new Crown Corporation that will hire only union workers for construction of major public projects.
  2. All construction worker payroll and benefits will run through this government Crown Corporation.
  3. The Crown Corporation will be called “BC Infrastructure Benefits Inc.” (BCIB) and will be considered the Employer of all employees working under the scope of the CBA.
  4. Contractors must recognize the BCIB as the employer.
  5. Open-shop companies can bid on projects but their employees will be required to join a designated union (the newly-created “Allied Infrastructure and Related Construction Council of BC”) after 30 days on the job.
  6. The Allied Infrastructure and Related Construction Council of BC is a conglomerate of the International Building Trades Unions (BTU).
  7. The first two projects that will be procured this way are:
    1. The Pattullo Bridge replacement project is currently in RFQ (until September 27)
    2. Kamloops-Alberta Highway 1 expansion to four lanes
  8. $0.32 per hour will be deducted from each worker’s pay cheque, and $0.25 of that will pay for the administration of the new Crown Corporation.
    1. $0.25 will be contributed to the Council Administration Fund
    2. $0.06 will be contributed in equal parts to each of the following: Rehabilitation Fund, Industry Health and Safety Fund, SkillPlan
    3. $0.01 will be contributed to the Jurisdictional Assignment Plan Fund
  9. The CBA includes employees hired to perform construction work on the project including Owner Operators, and including employees of Contractors who provide Security Guard and Fire Prevention on the Site.
  10. All unions, even if they are not a member of the BC Building Trades, are bound by this agreement.

Government Justification:

Premier Horgan claims this approach will drive apprenticeship, training, and employment opportunities for women and indigenous people, that projects will run more safely, efficiently, and economically, and that there will only be a modest 4 to 7 per cent increase in construction costs.

VICA’s Position:

  • VICA does not support this CBA; it contravenes many of our provincial body's (BCCA) Industry Policy Statements.
  • While Community Benefit Agreements can have positive impacts when done properly and in partnership with industry, in this instance the name “CBA” name is being co-opted to disguise a union labour agreement.
  • We believe it amounts to conscription of British Columbia's construction workforce.
  • This policy contravenes the obligation of government for fair, open and transparent procurement practices.
  • BC’s construction industry is facing a skilled worker shortage: restricting and creating barriers to employment and project opportunities will make this problem worse.
  • It is incorrect in today’s marketplace that union employers pay better, train more, offer better benefits packages, or prioritize safety more than open-shop employers.
  • The CBA potentially violates the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which guarantees our rights to freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, and the right to be treated equally.
  • This CBA tips the balance of power away from union employers to the unions themselves, subsequently undermining the role of all employers in the construction industry, whether union or open-shop.
  • The CBA will result in greater expense to taxpayers.

What You Can Do About It:

Join BCCA's grassroots letter writing campaign to tell Premier Horgan, your local MLAs, and the BC MP’s that represent our province in Ottawa that this CBA will not be accepted by our industry.


Register today for BCCA's Member-Only Town Hall Meeting 

This might be the most important industry topic you’ll discuss this year. As a respected and influential member of the Vancouver Island Construction Association, your presence and participation are crucial for our success as we work to craft an official industry response to government. Seating is limited. 

Date: Thursday, September 6, 2018 | 7:00 - 8:30 PM - Standing room still available!
Location: Coast Bastion Hotel, 11 Bastion Street, Nanaimo (map)


For meetings in Vancouver, Prince George, or Kelowna, click here.

To read the BC NDP CBA in full detail, click here.
To read our initial response to the CBA click here.
To read responses received so far from BC's MLAs, click here.

ECR air recon web size - cropped.jpg
September 07, 2018

Port Alberni Awards Largest Construction Contract in Municipal History

On September 4, 2018, Council for the City of Port Alberni unanimously passed a motion to award the main construction contract for the upcoming Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrades project to Tritech Group for $17,128,429.53 plus GST - the largest construction contract awarded in the City of Port Alberni’s history.
Read More
August 24, 2018

New BC Building and Plumbing Code

The new BC Building and Plumbing Code will be effective December 10, 2018 and will apply to building permits applied for on or after that date. The BC Fire Code is anticipated to be adopted in the fall of 2018 and effective December 10, 2018. Buildings with permits in place under the previous 2012 BC Building Code will generally not be affected by the adoption of the new code.
Read More
July 27, 2018

REPOST: Pattullo Procurement Strategy Takes BC Construction a Bridge Too Far

The new Pattullo Bridge Community Benefits Agreement patently illustrates what is unfair with our current government’s policy decision to mandate the nature and extent of procurement requirements in major public construction projects. For BCCA, an association that hinges its principles on fair, open and transparent procurement practices, this agreement is taking public policy in construction tendering a bridge too far.
Read More
July 23, 2018

[Op-Ed] Dana Taylor: B.C. needs prompt-payment legislation for contractors

When was the last time you bought groceries and told Save-On Foods that they would have to wait a couple of months before you would pay them? It would never fly. Trade contractors in British Columbia — those who build the structures in which you live, work, play and study — must also pay their expenses on time. But to get paid for their completed work, they must routinely wait and wait and wait.
Read More